2026 verdict
It works with Apple Home, Alexa, Google Home and Home Assistant, adds a light sensor for dark-only automations, covers 170 degrees against 100 and is rated for about 5 years on its batteries against 2. The
Eufy Motion Sensor reaches further, rated to 9 m against 7 m, and fits neatly into a eufy Security system, where it arms with Home, Away and Disarmed modes and can trigger eufy cameras; outside of that it only reaches Home Assistant, and it needs a eufy HomeBase to work at all. Choose the
Aqara Motion Sensor P1 for lighting and automations across platforms, and the
Eufy Motion Sensor if you are extending a eufy HomeBase security setup.
What owners say
Owners of both sensors report the same letdown: the real detection distance falls short of what the box promises, so placement matters with either one. Beyond that they describe different jobs. Aqara Motion Sensor P1 owners value fast triggering for lights, the small body, the light sensor and pairing with a generic Zigbee coordinator in Home Assistant, and they complain that slow movement slips past it, that its timer does not restart while someone stays in the room and that changing the battery means prying the case open. Eufy Motion Sensor owners praise pairing to the HomeBase in minutes, long battery life and uses like a mailbox alert or triggering a camera, while their complaints are that it only works with a HomeBase, has no siren of its own, can be set off by small animals outdoors and has no Alexa or Google Home support.