2026 verdict
Shelly 1 Mini Gen3 comes out ahead for most light circuits, as the smaller, lower priced and better rated of these two Shelly relays.
It fits a 29 x 35 x 16 mm body, switches 8A with dry and wet contact modes, and supports Matter, Apple Home, Alexa, Google Home, SmartThings and Home Assistant, all with a 3-year warranty. The
Shelly 1 Gen4 is the more capable relay: it switches 16A, adds full Bluetooth and Zigbee through a Zigbee hub, and routes Zigbee traffic for the rest of the mesh, in a larger 37 x 42 x 16 mm body. Both need a neutral wire, and neither is the one for energy readings: the Mini has no metering and the Gen4 does not document any. Pick the
Shelly 1 Mini Gen3 for lights and small loads in a tight box, and the
Shelly 1 Gen4 for heavier loads or a Zigbee home.
What owners say
Owners of both Shelly relays praise the same core: local control that responds instantly and keeps schedules running without the cloud, and dry contacts that solve garage door and irrigation jobs cheaply. Shelly 1 Mini Gen3 owners dwell on value and size, installs that take minutes, and a built-in web page that makes the app optional, while their recurring complaint is a misleading wiring diagram that sends first-timers to YouTube. Shelly 1 Gen4 owners talk more about protocol choice, detached mode for scene control and pool heater relays, and they warn that Zigbee pairing can be fiddly and underdocumented on hubs like Hubitat, that the box fit is tight and that some hit Android app problems.