Winner
15% OFF
$126.76
$149.99
Updated October 2026
Data from the official Asus and NETGEAR sites.
2026 verdict
Asus RT-BE58U wins the 2026 matchup against NETGEAR Nighthawk RS140, mainly on price, warranty, and mesh Wi-Fi.
The main reason it wins is price, warranty, and mesh Wi-Fi, and LAN port count and LAN 2.5 gbps RJ45 ports strengthen that case. NETGEAR Nighthawk RS140 can still be the right pick, but only if rating and max Wi-Fi speed outweigh the wider strengths of Asus RT-BE58U. That is why the final call still favors Asus RT-BE58U.
News by email
Still comparing? Get what's new by email
New releases and the smart home news worth knowing, in your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe in one click.
| Feature | Asus RT-BE58U | NETGEAR Nighthawk RS140 | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price | $126.76 | $170.51 | Asus RT-BE58U |
| Rating | 4.0 | 4.2 | NETGEAR Nighthawk RS140 |
| Warranty | 3 years | 1 year | Asus RT-BE58U |
| Max Wi-Fi Speed | 3.6 Gbps | 5 Gbps | NETGEAR Nighthawk RS140 |
| Mesh Wi-Fi | YES | NO | Asus RT-BE58U |
| LAN Port Count | 5 | 3 | Asus RT-BE58U |
| LAN 2.5 Gbps RJ45 Ports | 1 | 0 | Asus RT-BE58U |
| WAN & Failover | Multi-WAN, WAN Failover | None | Asus RT-BE58U |
| USB Storage | FTP, Samba, Time Machine, Media Sharing | None | Asus RT-BE58U |
| MLO (Multi-Link Operation) | YES | NO | Asus RT-BE58U |
| Wi-Fi 6E (802.11ax) | NO | NO | Tie |
| Wi-Fi 7 (802.11be) | YES | YES | Tie |
Winner
15% OFF
$126.76
$149.99
- + Price: $126.76
- + Warranty: 3 years
- + Mesh Wi-Fi: YES
- - Rating: 4.0 vs 4.2
- - Max Wi-Fi Speed: 3.6 Gbps vs 5 Gbps
$170.51
- + Rating: 4.2
- + Max Wi-Fi Speed: 5 Gbps
- - Price: $170.51 vs $126.76
- - Warranty: 1 year vs 3 years
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is better overall: Asus RT-BE58U or NETGEAR Nighthawk RS140?
Asus RT-BE58U has the stronger overall profile in this comparison, especially for price, warranty, and mesh Wi-Fi.
What is the biggest difference between Asus RT-BE58U and NETGEAR Nighthawk RS140?
Price is one of the clearest differences: Asus RT-BE58U lists $126.76, while NETGEAR Nighthawk RS140 lists $170.51.
Which one looks better on price?
Asus RT-BE58U is listed at $126.76, while NETGEAR Nighthawk RS140 is listed at $170.51. Asus RT-BE58U (better spec).
Who should buy Asus RT-BE58U?
Choose Asus RT-BE58U if your priority is price and warranty and that matters more than rating.
Who should buy NETGEAR Nighthawk RS140?
Choose NETGEAR Nighthawk RS140 if your priority is rating and max Wi-Fi speed and that matters more than price.
Our store on AmazonShop our ideas on AmazonLists of the smart home setups we would put together ourselves, ready to add to your Amazon cart.Shop on AmazonFull comparison table
Compare all 45 Routers side by side
You are looking at two of them. The full table lines up all Routers in the catalog with the same specs, so you can filter by what you need and sort by price or rating.
- 45 Routers
- 82 specs compared
- 76 filters
- Routers
UniFi Dream Router 5G Max
- Routers
UniFi Dream Router 7
- Routers
UniFi Express 7
- Routers
Cloud Gateway Ultra
- Routers
Outdoor 7
- Routers
Deco BE63
- Routers
Archer AX21
- Routers
7
- Routers
Deco X55
- Routers
Nighthawk RS700S
- Routers
Deco BE23
- Routers
Archer AXE75
- Routers
Archer BE400
- Routers
Nighthawk RS90
- Routers
Pro 7
- Routers
RT-BE88U
- Routers
Deco BE25
- Routers
ZenWiFi BT6
- Routers
Archer BE230
- Routers
ROG Rapture GT-BE98 Pro
- Mini PCs
Ascent GX10 (128GB + 1TB)
- Mini PCs
Chromebox 5a (Celeron 4GB + 128GB)
- Mini PCs
NUC 13 Pro Slim (i7 16GB + 512GB)
- Mini PCs
NUC 14 Pro Tall (Ultra 7 32GB + 1TB)
- Mini PCs
NUC 15 Pro+ (Ultra 9 32GB + 1TB)
- Mini PCs
NUC 15 Pro Slim (Core 5 16GB + 512GB)
- Mini PCs
NUC 16 Pro (Ultra 7 16GB + 512GB)
- Mini PCs
NUC 16 Pro (Ultra X7 32GB + 1TB)
- Mini PCs
ROG GR70 (RTX 5070 32GB + 2TB)
- Mini PCs
ROG NUC 16 (RTX 5060 32GB + 1TB)
- Mini PCs
ROG NUC 16 (RTX 5070 Ti 32GB + 1TB)
- Mini PCs
ROG NUC 16 (RTX 5080 32GB + 1TB)
- Mini PCs
ROG NUC 16 (RTX 5080 64GB + 2TB)
- Mini PCs
ROG NUC 2025 (RTX 5070 32GB + 1TB)
- Mini PCs
ROG NUC 2025 (RTX 5070 32GB + 2TB)
- Mini PCs
ROG NUC 2025 (RTX 5070 Ti 32GB + 2TB)
- Mini PCs
ROG NUC 2025 (RTX 5080 32GB + 2TB)
- Routers
ROG Rapture GT-BE19000AI
- Routers
ROG Rapture GT-BE98 Pro
- Routers
ROG Strix GS-BE12000