Aqara Smart Wall Switch (No Neutral) - Double vs Lutron Caseta Original Smart Dimmer Switch

Between a two-gang Zigbee switch and a single-gang RF dimmer, both wired for boxes with no neutral, the Aqara Smart Wall Switch (No Neutral) - Double comes out on top on price, on connectivity, on integrations (it adds Matter support through an Aqara hub that the Lutron lacks entirely), and simply on controlling two circuits instead of one. The Lutron Caseta Original Smart Dimmer Switch keeps just one advantage, a better rating, plus a functional edge the Aqara switch is not documented to match: dimming, since the Caseta is purpose-built for it and the Aqara switch is not marketed as a dimmer. Both need a hub to unlock full smart features, an Aqara or third-party Zigbee coordinator for the Aqara switch, the Lutron Smart Hub for the Caseta, and neither needs a neutral wire. Buyers with two circuits to cover in a no-neutral box who want Matter support should choose the Aqara Smart Wall Switch (No Neutral) - Double; buyers with a single dimmable circuit and no need for Matter should choose the Lutron Caseta Original Smart Dimmer Switch instead.